16/04/2026

The Messy Middle: Why Marketing Is Rarely a Straight Line to Sale

Nigel Wilkinson

Managing Director of Daneswood. Nigel has been in sales and marketing since the 1980's and run digital marketing agencies since 2000.

Most people like to think of the buying journey as neat and predictable. Someone becomes aware of your business.  They compare a few options.  They make a decision and buy. 

In reality, that almost never happens that way. It’s what Google refers to the space between awareness and purchase as “the messy middle”, and it’s exactly where most buying decisions are either won or lost. 

Understanding how the messy middle works – and how to influence it – is critical if you want your marketing to drive real, repeatable growth. Because the way people buy in 2026 is totally different from just six years ago, let alone 10 or 20 years ago. 

What Is the Messy Middle? 

The messy middle is the period between someone first becoming aware of a product or service and actually deciding to buy it. 

During this phase, people don’t move in a straight line; they don’t drop into a neat sales funnel. They loop backwards and forwards. They pause. They compare. They disappear for weeks. Then they reappear seemingly out of nowhere, ready to enquire or purchase. 

This is where uncertainty lives if you are in sales and marketing. 

People are asking themselves questions like: 

  • Do I trust this business? 
  • Do they really understand my problem? 
  • Are they credible, do I trust them? 
  • Have I seen them before? 
  • Do they feel established and reliable? 
  • What do other people think of them? 

At this stage, you’re not just being evaluated on price or features. You’re being assessed on signals of trust and expertise. 

Why Intent Signals Matter More Than Ever 

In the messy middle, people are constantly assessing signals. 

  • One website visit is rarely enough to make a decision.   
  • One social post won’t tip the scales. 
  • One email marketing newsletter won’t make an impression.  
  • One ad impression won’t win the deal. 

Instead, people need repeated exposure. Every time someone sees your brand, reads your insight, watches your video, or hears your name mentioned, it subtly moves them closer to trust. 

That’s why being visible across multiple channels is so important. 

Winning the Messy Middle Means Being Everywhere Your Buyers Look 

You don’t need to be on every platform for the sake of it – but you do need to show up consistently across the places your audience already uses. 

That might include: 

  • LinkedIn for authority and professional credibility 
  • X (Twitter) for commentary, insight, and opinion 
  • Facebook and Instagram for familiarity and brand reinforcement 
  • TikTok for reach and human connection 
  • Blogging for depth, SEO, and expertise 
  • Podcasts for trust and long‑form thinking 
  • Your website is the foundation stone of your marketing 
  • Email marketing for ongoing relationship‑building 

Each channel creates another touch point. And each touch point reduces friction when it’s finally time to make a decision. 

The goal isn’t vanity metrics.  The goal is familiarity at the moment of choice. 

Know, Like, Trust Still Wins 

People don’t buy from businesses they don’t recognise. 

They buy from brands that feel familiar.   

From experts who appear consistently.   

From companies that have already demonstrated value before the sales conversation begins. 

Being visible and helpful across multiple formats accelerates the “know, like, trust” journey – especially in longer or higher‑value buying cycles. 

If you’re absent during the messy middle, someone else won’t be. 

The Truth About Tracking Marketing Performance 

Yes – you should absolutely track what can be tracked. 

This includes things like: 

  • Website traffic and conversions 
  • Telephone calls from your website 
  • Lead sources 
  • Email opens and clicks 
  • Paid media performance 
  • Enquiry and sales data 

These metrics matter. They inform better decisions and improve efficiency over time. 

But it’s also vital to accept a hard truth. Not everything can be tracked, nor should it be! 

Why Attribution Is Imperfect (and Always Will Be) 

A prospect might: 

  • Read one of your blog posts 
  • See you on LinkedIn a week later 
  • Watch a short video on Instagram 
  • Hear you mentioned on a podcast 
  • Then Google your company and make an enquiry 

Only the last step is visible in analytics. The rest of the journey still happened – it just wasn’t measurable. Relying solely on last‑click attribution dramatically undervalues the content and channels that actually built trust and confidence in the first place. 

This doesn’t mean you abandon tracking.  It means you don’t let imperfect data undermine smart marketing. 

Consistency Beats Attribution 

The aim isn’t perfect attribution. The aim is consistent presence.  

  • Show up regularly.   
  • Share insight.   
  • Demonstrate expertise.   
  • Be visible where your audience already spends time. 

Because when someone finally reaches the end of the messy middle and is ready to make a decision, the business that wins is usually the one that feels familiar. 

Not the cheapest.   

Not the loudest.   

The most trusted. 

If you’d like to understand how the messy middle can guide your sales process, please do contact us!

Find a Solution That Works For You

Apply For Your Marketing Review.

Straightforward website and SEO reviews, recorded by experienced marketing experts, not AI.

We’ll look at your website, run a report on your SEO Health then talk you through the results in a 15-minute video, which we’ll send you completely free of charge within 5-10 working days.